CPTSD & Trauma Patterns

They Called It Kindness. It Was the Fourth Survival Response.

Your kindness can be real and a survival response at the same time.

By Carrie Davidson, BSPH, BSN, RN, Registered nurse and certified trauma recovery coach
Published · 6 min read

This article is trauma recovery education, not therapy, diagnosis, or medical treatment. It is not a substitute for care from a licensed mental-health or medical professional. If you are working with a therapist or physician, let this walk beside that care. It does not replace it.

The nicest thing about you might be a wound.

Everybody knows fight or flight. This year the trauma world finally started saying the other two out loud, freeze and fawn, and the one that keeps stopping people cold is fawn. Because fawn doesn't look like a trauma response. Fawn looks like a good woman. Fawn looks like the friend who always texts back, the employee who never says no, the one who can read the temperature of a room before she's even put her bag down. Fawn looks like everything the world rewards you for. And that's exactly why it's the hardest one to put down.

Let me tell you where I learned mine. I was six and I was the adult in the room. Not metaphorically. There was a real adult who could not be the adult, and there was me, small, hypervigilant, already scanning faces for the weather. I learned that if I got it right, if I anticipated what someone needed before they had to ask, if I made myself easy and useful and good, the room stayed safe a little longer. Later, when I was older and in worse rooms, when I was somewhere I should not have been and went by a name that was not mine to stay alive, that same wiring is the thing that kept me breathing. I became whoever the moment needed. I have been so many people. The constant underneath all of them was the same six-year-old, reading the room, managing the danger, trading herself for one more hour of safe.

Here's the nurse part, the part I need you to actually hear. Fawn is not a character flaw. It is a documented survival response, the body's fourth gear after fight, flight, and freeze. When fighting will get you hurt and running isn't possible and freezing doesn't make it stop, the nervous system reaches for the last tool it has: appease. Make the threat like you. Become useful to the very thing that scares you. It runs through the same autonomic machinery as all the others, the same flood of stress chemistry, the same brainstem doing math faster than thought. The difference is it doesn't read as fear from the outside. It reads as warmth. So you get praised for it. You get called selfless, mature, easy, low-maintenance. The world hands you a gold star for the exact behavior that's quietly costing you your own center. And a nervous system will absolutely keep doing the thing it gets rewarded for, long after the original danger is dead and gone.

The world hands you a gold star for the exact behavior that's quietly costing you your own center.

That's the trap nobody names. The other trauma responses eventually hurt you enough that you go looking for help. Fight burns your relationships down. Flight leaves you exhausted and alone. Freeze gets you called lazy or checked-out until you can't stand yourself. But fawn? Fawn gets you promoted. Fawn gets you married. Fawn gets you a reputation as the strong one, the dependable one, the one who can handle it. The cost is just slower and quieter. It's the resentment you can't explain. It's saying yes with your mouth while something in your chest goes cold. It's getting to forty and realizing you genuinely do not know what you want for dinner because you have spent your whole life answering a different question, which is: what do you need from me so I'm safe?

And here's where it turned for me, and it took a long time. The wiring that made me disappear into other people is the same wiring that makes me a good nurse, a good coach, a person who can walk into a room full of someone else's worst day and know what it needs. I'm not trying to delete the radar. The radar is a gift. I'm just learning, slowly, in real time, to point it at myself too. To let the same exquisite attention I've always spent on everyone else land, for ten seconds, on me. To notice my own weather. To let "no" be a complete sentence and not a betrayal.

So have you, probably. If you've ever been the one who held it all together, the one nobody worried about, the one who could read a room but couldn't tell you what she felt in her own body, hear me: that wasn't your goodness. Or it wasn't only your goodness. It was a child who learned that staying safe meant staying useful, and never got told she was allowed to stop.

I want to be honest about where I'm standing. I still fawn. I caught myself doing it twice this week, smoothing something over that didn't need smoothing, apologizing for taking up space I was entitled to. I'm not on the far side of this telling you how I beat it. I'm in it, learning to feel the moment my body offers itself up to keep the peace, and sometimes, just sometimes, choosing not to take the deal.

This one's for the helpers and the fixers and the easy ones. The women who never made anybody nervous. The good girls who were really just scared kids with excellent manners. Your kindness can be real and a survival response at the same time. You get to keep the heart and put down the bracing. You're allowed to be a person now, not just a shape that other people find safe.

Pick up the pen, y'all. The good girl was doing her best. She can rest now.

Carrie

Carrie Davidson, registered nurse and trauma recovery coach

Carrie Davidson, BSPH, BSN, RN

Registered nurse and certified trauma recovery coach; the nurse who became her own patient. She writes about the overlap of complex trauma and addiction: the same wound, telling itself in two different languages. Author of the memoir Addicted to Trauma.

More about Carrie →

Keep reading

If this spoke to you

A free companion

The Trauma Tree Workbook

A printable workbook for tracing a pattern back to its root: the roots, the trunk, and the branches it grows in your life today. Education, not treatment.

Get the worksheet (free) →

The essays are the free layer of this work. When you want company inside it, here are the ways we can work together.