The Writing Life · 10 min read

What it means to write a memoir while still living inside the story.

By Carrie Davidson

The morning I wrote the prologue of my memoir, I was sitting in my car in a parking lot. I had just left a therapy session where I had described, for the first time out loud, what had happened the night before, the gap in my memory, the blood, the face of someone I loved and had hurt without any conscious awareness of doing it. My therapist had handed me a tissue. I had driven to the nearest parking lot and sat there for forty minutes before I could bring myself to start the car.

And then I opened my laptop and started writing.

Not because I knew I was writing a memoir. I didn't, not yet. I started writing because writing has always been the thing I do when something is too large for the inside of my head. The page has always been where I go to figure out what I actually think.

What I didn't fully understand then, and what I want to try to articulate here, for anyone who is considering writing about their own life while they are still inside it, is what that choice actually costs. And what it actually gives back. Because both things are real, and I don't think either one is talked about honestly enough.

The Problem With Writing a Story That Isn't Finished Yet

The traditional wisdom about memoir is that you need distance. Time. The perspective that only comes from having fully moved through an experience and arrived somewhere on the other side of it.

I understand why that wisdom exists. Distance protects you. It protects your readers. It allows you to give the story a shape and a meaning that you genuinely can't see when you're standing in the middle of it.

But distance also does something else. It tidies things up. It allows you to organize the mess of a lived life into something that has the clean arc of a narrative, where the cause and effect lines up neatly and the protagonist arrives at the ending having learned exactly the right lessons in exactly the right order. That version of a life is legible. It is also, in my experience, not quite true.

The mess is where the truth lives. The not-yet-understanding. The still-in-the-middle-of-it. That moment, in its raw and specific texture, is the thing I most wanted to put on the page. Not because I wanted to perform my own suffering. But because that is the moment that everyone who has ever lived inside a pattern they couldn't stop making knows in their body, even if they have never had words for it.

So I wrote it that way. And it cost me things I didn't fully anticipate when I started.

The People in the Story

The hardest part of writing memoir is not the writing. It is the people.

Every person who appears in your memoir is a real person who did not consent to being a character in your book. They have their own interior life, their own version of events, their own interpretation of what happened and what it meant.

I thought about this constantly while I was writing. The people I wrote about who had hurt me, I wanted to be honest about what they did without making them into villains, because villains are simple and people are not simple. The people who were still in my life while I was writing, those were the ones that kept me up at night.

Before this book goes to publication, every person who is identifiable in it will have the opportunity to read what I have written about them. Not to change it, the story is mine and I am the one telling it, but to know. To not be blindsided. To have the conversation with me before the conversation happens in public.

This is not a legal requirement. It is an ethical one. And it is one of the most important commitments I have made in the process of writing this book.

The Accountability Problem

Here is the thing about writing your own story while you are still in the middle of it: you are also writing about the harm you caused. Not just the harm that was done to you.

That was the part I was least prepared for. The patterns I was running caused harm. To people I loved. People who deserved better than what my unhealed places gave them.

Writing about that honestly, naming it clearly, without letting the explanation become an excuse, was the most difficult writing I have ever done. Because the temptation, when you understand the mechanism of your own trauma, is to let that understanding do too much work. To let it function as an absolution you haven't fully earned.

The distinction I kept coming back to was the one between explanation and excuse. Explanation says: here is the mechanism. Here is why this happened. Excuse says: and therefore I am not responsible. Those are very different things, and I was determined not to let the first slide into the second.

Pain can be valid and still become destructive in the wrong hands. Even your own. Understanding why you did something does not undo its effects on the people it touched. Both of these things are true simultaneously, and holding both of them, the compassion for yourself and the accountability for your impact, is some of the hardest emotional work memoir asks of you.

What Writing It While Still Inside It Actually Gave Me

Writing the memoir while I was still in the middle of recovery meant that the book had to stay honest. I couldn't pretend to an understanding I didn't yet have. I couldn't write a tidy ending that wasn't true yet. I had to sit with the not-knowing and write from inside it, which is both the most terrifying and the most useful thing a writer can do.

It also meant that the writing itself became part of the recovery. Every time I sat down to write a chapter, I was being a witness to my own experience in a way that my nervous system had never fully allowed before. I was slowing down. I was staying with something long enough to put words around it. I was refusing, for the duration of the writing, to take the exit.

That is not a small thing for someone whose primary survival response was flight.

And there is something else. Writing about your own life, really writing about it, not the curated version but the actual version, is an act of radical self-acknowledgment. It says: this happened. It says: I was here. It says: this experience, this specific textured human experience of being me in this body navigating this particular set of impossible things, is real and it matters and it deserves to be recorded.

Writing my memoir gave me that. Not from an audience. From myself. I gave it to myself. And that, it turns out, was something I had needed for a very long time.

For Anyone Who Is Considering This

If you are sitting with a story that feels too large for the inside of your head, and you are wondering whether you should write it, here is what I want to say:

You do not need to be finished healing to write about your healing. You do not need to have caused no harm to write honestly about the harm you caused. You do not need the tidy ending to start telling the story.

But go in with your eyes open. Know that the people you write about are real people. Have the hard conversations before the book comes out, not after. Hold your explanation separate from your excuse. Write both sides of the story with equal honesty and equal compassion.

And write it in your own voice. Not the voice you think a memoir is supposed to sound like. Your actual voice. The one that is still figuring things out. The one that doesn't have all the answers yet. That voice is the one that will reach the people who need to be reached.

Because the person who needs to read your story is sitting somewhere right now, inside their own unfinished story, wondering if anyone else has ever felt exactly what they are feeling. And the most useful thing you can give them is not the version where you had it all figured out. It is the version where you were still in it, and kept going anyway.

That is the memoir worth writing.

Free · The Sunday Letter

A quiet letter on healing,
arriving each Sunday evening.

Reflections on CPTSD, recovery, and slowly coming back to yourself - written from lived experience, not a marketing calendar.

No spam. Unsubscribe whenever.